This profile is currently being reviewed by the BestForex.io editorial team. Some information may be incomplete or subject to change.
Advantage Futures Review
Advantage Futures is a Chicago futures clearing firm, not a simple forex broker. The CFTC fined it $395,000 in 2023 for failing to properly watch years of client trades.
Min Deposit
N/A
Spreads From
Not applicable, Advantage charges per contract commissions, not forex spreads
Max Leverage
Set per client margin agreement, not a fixed public figure
Platforms
Client chosen front end platforms, Direct exchange connectivity
Pros
- Registered CFTC futures commission merchant and NFA member since 2003
- Clearing member of CME Group, ICE, Cboe, and several other major exchanges
- Publishes yearly net capital figures, over $39 million as of mid 2025
- Agency only model, so the firm does not trade against its own clients
Cons
- CFTC fined it $395,000 in 2023 for years of trade surveillance failures
- Over 12.8 million cleared contracts went unmonitored between 2018 and 2022
- Not built for casual retail traders, mainly serves professional groups
- No fixed minimum deposit or public spread, pricing is set case by case
Advantage Futures LLC started in Chicago in 2003 under founder Joseph Guinan. It is registered with the CFTC and is a member of the NFA, under member ID 327359. The firm clears trades on CME Group, ICE, Cboe Futures Exchange, and other major exchanges for professional and institutional clients.
In September 2023, the CFTC ordered Advantage to pay a $395,000 penalty. The order found that surveillance gaps let over 12.8 million cleared contracts go unmonitored for disruptive trading between 2018 and 2022, close to 1.5 percent of client volume in that period. Advantage says it has since hired new staff and fixed its data feeds.
Advantage mainly serves proprietary trading groups, hedge funds, and professional traders rather than casual retail traders, though individuals can apply. There is no listed minimum deposit or standard spread, since pricing and margin terms are set per client through a proposal process, not a fixed retail account.
Max Leverage
Set per client margin agreement, not a fixed public figure
Spreads From
Not applicable, Advantage charges per contract commissions, not forex spreads
Platforms
Regulation, fund safety, track record
Spreads, execution, leverage
Platform quality, charting, features
Analysis, webinars, learning materials
Support quality, responsiveness
Mobile app quality, features
